creed and pearl jam

creedmarine81 · 09-04-2007, 03:46 PM

i dont know one irritating comparison i hear alot is how creed sounds like pearl jam........ i dont see no similarity at all ...... vedders voice is not even as strong as stapps ... pearl jam is good but them and creed sound so different.. anybody with an opinion

J.T. · 09-04-2007, 04:00 PM

No I don't really see the similarities. But people are going to cream you with rants on how Vedders voice is better than Stapps...I don't agree, it just happens a lot.

bilal · 09-04-2007, 05:19 PM

this IS an IRRITATING comparison

They both sound different and they both have different singing styles..... Eddie Vedder has been singing for over 17 years now and has done all sorts of songs... from his early youth years of Ten and Vs till the very melodic undertones of Binaural and Riot Act....... Scott has his own Baritone.... Musically, Creed and Pearl Jam are way way different....

no Comparison!.. save for one that they both are AWESOME bands....

Scorpion King · 09-04-2007, 05:26 PM

There are some similarities between their voices, but not enough to warrant the accusations that Stapp ripped off Vedder's vox. Now, there have been countless incidents of things like that really happening. For example, alot of the singers in eighties hard rock bands sounded like banshees on their period (don't get me wrong, I love bands like Poison and Tesla, but they all had these high-pitched similar vocals). Trivium has been sounding a little too much like James Hetfield of late. Visions Of Atlantis sounds really similar to Nightwish. And there are other examples. But I don't think that the Vedder/Stapp comparison is valid. They are two different bands with two different messages and two different sounds.

Now I will say this; as much as I love Creed, it has not made the same impact on music as Pearl Jam has. While Creed's effect on the industry was largely temporary, Pearl Jam has had a much greater impact. Not saying that Pearl Jam is a better band, but it will be remembered by more people than will Creed, and it deserves to.

Agent D · 09-05-2007, 05:20 PM

I always thought it was interesting before I started listening to Pearl Jam and really becoming a fan of theirs. Suddenly, I realized what people were talking about.

Dogstar · 09-06-2007, 01:52 AM

As much as I love Creed, Eddie Vedder a bajillion times the lyricist Scott Stapp could ever be. He's an amazing storyteller, both in words and voice.

Ana4Stapp · 09-06-2007, 05:38 AM

Well I have to confess that at the beginning I saw similarities about their voices...wasnt sure who was singing....but like Bilal pointed here....they were/are awesome bands, so no comparison.

J.T. · 09-06-2007, 04:13 PM

Scott Stapp pwns Eddit Vedder.

bilal · 09-07-2007, 01:05 PM

Redeemer · 09-12-2007, 05:53 PM

Fail -.- Eddie pwns Scott. I mean, look at PJ's career. You cannot deny that kind of success...and I don't mean success as far as sales or anything like that. I mean success as far as impact.

As far as Vedder and Stapp sounding alike, that's just bull. They may have some trace similarities, but not enough to warrant a whole argument. I mean, Ved's got a whole different style going on. Completely different. So what's the deal?

People sure as hell like to find random things to argue about.

HeavensOnFire · 09-13-2007, 10:58 AM

Quote: (Originally Posted by Scorpion King) There are some similarities between their voices, but not enough to warrant the accusations that Stapp ripped off Vedder's vox. Now, there have been countless incidents of things like that really happening. For example, alot of the singers in eighties hard rock bands sounded like banshees on their period (don't get me wrong, I love bands like Poison and Tesla, but they all had these high-pitched similar vocals). Trivium has been sounding a little too much like James Hetfield of late. Visions Of Atlantis sounds really similar to Nightwish. And there are other examples. But I don't think that the Vedder/Stapp comparison is valid. They are two different bands with two different messages and two different sounds.

Now I will say this; as much as I love Creed, it has not made the same impact on music as Pearl Jam has. While Creed's effect on the industry was largely temporary, Pearl Jam has had a much greater impact. Not saying that Pearl Jam is a better band, but it will be remembered by more people than will Creed, and it deserves to.

well my thread was to long haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

i,ll have to make my own to comment yours i

Buddah · 10-23-2007, 03:02 PM

Is this a time warp?

Buddah · 10-23-2007, 03:07 PM

i swore this was a topic of conversation about 10 years ago

who the hell still cares about scott stapp or creed for that matter?

Buddah · 10-23-2007, 03:09 PM

I do!

Buddah · 10-23-2007, 03:14 PM

Vedder wish he could write songs like stapp

09-04-2007, 03:46 PM	#1
creedmarine81 USER INFO » Status: Misconception Posts: 108 Joined: Aug 2007 Currently: Offline	creed and pearl jam i dont know one irritating comparison i hear alot is how creed sounds like pearl jam........ i dont see no similarity at all ...... vedders voice is not even as strong as stapps ... pearl jam is good but them and creed sound so different.. anybody with an opinion

09-04-2007, 04:00 PM	#2
J.T. USER INFO » Status: Broken Dream Posts: 170 Joined: Jan 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam No I don't really see the similarities. But people are going to cream you with rants on how Vedders voice is better than Stapps...I don't agree, it just happens a lot. __________________ "WARNING:HIGHLY TOXIC LINK, CLICK AT YOUR OWN RISK!

09-04-2007, 05:19 PM	#3
bilal USER INFO » Status: Said Eyes Posts: 4,615 Joined: Feb 2006 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam this IS an IRRITATING comparison They both sound different and they both have different singing styles..... Eddie Vedder has been singing for over 17 years now and has done all sorts of songs... from his early youth years of Ten and Vs till the very melodic undertones of Binaural and Riot Act....... Scott has his own Baritone.... Musically, Creed and Pearl Jam are way way different.... no Comparison!.. save for one that they both are AWESOME bands.... __________________ ~~~AB-III~~~ You Should Never Come This Way To Test The Hands Of Fate You Don't Belong Here

09-04-2007, 05:26 PM	#4
Scorpion King USER INFO » Status: Misconception Posts: 126 Joined: Jul 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam There are some similarities between their voices, but not enough to warrant the accusations that Stapp ripped off Vedder's vox. Now, there have been countless incidents of things like that really happening. For example, alot of the singers in eighties hard rock bands sounded like banshees on their period (don't get me wrong, I love bands like Poison and Tesla, but they all had these high-pitched similar vocals). Trivium has been sounding a little too much like James Hetfield of late. Visions Of Atlantis sounds really similar to Nightwish. And there are other examples. But I don't think that the Vedder/Stapp comparison is valid. They are two different bands with two different messages and two different sounds. Now I will say this; as much as I love Creed, it has not made the same impact on music as Pearl Jam has. While Creed's effect on the industry was largely temporary, Pearl Jam has had a much greater impact. Not saying that Pearl Jam is a better band, but it will be remembered by more people than will Creed, and it deserves to.

09-05-2007, 05:20 PM	#5
Agent D USER INFO » Status: Wound Up Posts: 1,138 Joined: Feb 2003 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam I always thought it was interesting before I started listening to Pearl Jam and really becoming a fan of theirs. Suddenly, I realized what people were talking about.

09-06-2007, 01:52 AM	#6
Dogstar Forum Diplomat USER INFO » Status: Young Grown Old Posts: 21,345 Joined: Sep 2002 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam As much as I love Creed, Eddie Vedder a bajillion times the lyricist Scott Stapp could ever be. He's an amazing storyteller, both in words and voice. __________________ Silly monkeys give them thumbs they make a club and beat their brother down. How they survive so misguided is a mystery.

09-06-2007, 04:13 PM	#8
J.T. USER INFO » Status: Broken Dream Posts: 170 Joined: Jan 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam Scott Stapp pwns Eddit Vedder. __________________ "WARNING:HIGHLY TOXIC LINK, CLICK AT YOUR OWN RISK!

09-07-2007, 01:05 PM	#9
bilal USER INFO » Status: Said Eyes Posts: 4,615 Joined: Feb 2006 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam - __________________ ~~~AB-III~~~ You Should Never Come This Way To Test The Hands Of Fate You Don't Belong Here

09-13-2007, 10:58 AM	#11
HeavensOnFire USER INFO » Status: Wound Up Posts: 1,070 Joined: Oct 2006 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam Quote: (Originally Posted by Scorpion King) There are some similarities between their voices, but not enough to warrant the accusations that Stapp ripped off Vedder's vox. Now, there have been countless incidents of things like that really happening. For example, alot of the singers in eighties hard rock bands sounded like banshees on their period (don't get me wrong, I love bands like Poison and Tesla, but they all had these high-pitched similar vocals). Trivium has been sounding a little too much like James Hetfield of late. Visions Of Atlantis sounds really similar to Nightwish. And there are other examples. But I don't think that the Vedder/Stapp comparison is valid. They are two different bands with two different messages and two different sounds. Now I will say this; as much as I love Creed, it has not made the same impact on music as Pearl Jam has. While Creed's effect on the industry was largely temporary, Pearl Jam has had a much greater impact. Not saying that Pearl Jam is a better band, but it will be remembered by more people than will Creed, and it deserves to. well my thread was to long haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa i,ll have to make my own to comment yours i __________________ When NO One Else Can Understand Me When Everything I Do Is Wrong You Give Hope And Consolation You Give Me Strength To Carry On, And Your Always There To Lend A Hand In Everything I Do That The Wonder The WONDER Of You And When You Smile The World Is Brighter YOU Touch My Hand And Im Queen Your KISS To Me Is Worth A Fourtune Your Love For Me Is Everything I,ll Guess I,ll Never Know The Reason Why You Love As You Do Thats Just The Wonder The Wonder Of You

10-23-2007, 03:02 PM	#12
Buddah Banned USER INFO » Status: Illusion Posts: 16 Joined: Oct 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam Is this a time warp?

10-23-2007, 03:07 PM	#13
Buddah Banned USER INFO » Status: Illusion Posts: 16 Joined: Oct 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam i swore this was a topic of conversation about 10 years ago who the hell still cares about scott stapp or creed for that matter?

10-23-2007, 03:09 PM	#14
Buddah Banned USER INFO » Status: Illusion Posts: 16 Joined: Oct 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam I do!

10-23-2007, 03:14 PM	#15
Buddah Banned USER INFO » Status: Illusion Posts: 16 Joined: Oct 2007 Currently: Offline	Re: creed and pearl jam Vedder wish he could write songs like stapp

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

User Name		Remember Me?
Password