Stapp vs. Kennedy - Page 3

The Lithium · 09-12-2005, 04:48 PM

Okay people, Myles are still owning Stapp big! Myles has 54 against Scott's poor 15!! Myles is MORE than half way!! (First to reach 100 wins, remember?)

titan9 · 09-12-2005, 05:22 PM

Something tells me if looks were rated 2 and ability 1, that it would be the opposite. Or at least not as lopsided as it is.

Or if this were posted at PBF.....nah, bad idea.

RMadd · 09-12-2005, 06:26 PM

stapp's quite the stud, but myles' voice is substantially superior

Tremontixriffs · 09-12-2005, 07:54 PM

Quote: (Originally Posted by titan9) Something tells me if looks were rated 2 and ability 1, that it would be the opposite. Or at least not as lopsided as it is.

Or if this were posted at PBF.....nah, bad idea.

Alright people lets be serious looks aside... Myles is a good singer and does have a good range, however his voice leaves alot to be desired...Mainly after about 15- 20 min I cant take listening to him anymore, he almost kills the ears. Maybe some of his songs from Mayfield which were more his style I dont mind.

Second Scott stapp is the real deal, He may be arrogant at times or whatever but when it comes down to it he had way more success as a singer and a writer than myles could ever dream. myles may be the better musician and may be a better schooled singer but Stapp didn't need all that to become a great frontman, and when it comes to singing a ballad, kennedy couldn't come close...My ears wanted to blow after listening to in loving memory, it would have sounded so much better had stapp sung it.

Finally,
Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career as where with kennedy, Alter Bridge will continue to be a great "band" with a seventies/eighties wannabe, not that he is god awlful, I like bridge but creed will be remeber always.

Ana4Stapp · 09-12-2005, 09:00 PM

Quote: (Originally Posted by Tremontixriffs) Alright people lets be serious looks aside... Myles is a good singer and does have a good range, however his voice leaves alot to be desired...Mainly after about 15- 20 min I cant take listening to him anymore, he almost kills the ears. Maybe some of his songs from Mayfield which were more his style I dont mind.

Second Scott stapp is the real deal, He may be arrogant at times or whatever but when it comes down to it he had way more success as a singer and a writer than myles could ever dream. myles may be the better musician and may be a better schooled singer but Stapp didn't need all that to become a great frontman, and when it comes to singing a ballad, kennedy couldn't come close...My ears wanted to blow after listening to in loving memory, it would have sounded so much better had stapp sung it.

Finally,
Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career as where with kennedy, Alter Bridge will continue to be a great "band" with a seventies/eighties wannabe, not that he is god awlful, I like bridge but creed will be remeber always.

Just one question here: have you already listened to Mayfield Four songs???? Really?

ctfan · 09-13-2005, 12:15 AM

Stapp gets 3 pts from me.

Quote: but when it comes down to it he had way more success as a singer and a writer than myles could ever dream. myles may be the better musician and may be a better schooled singer but Stapp didn't need all that to become a great frontman, and when it comes to singing a ballad, kennedy couldn't come close...

Yep.

Quote: Myles is a good singer and does have a good range, however his voice leaves alot to be desired...Mainly after about 15- 20 min I cant take listening to him anymore, he almost kills the ears.

Yep.

Quote: Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career

Yep.

Muad'Dib · 09-13-2005, 06:21 AM

Quote: (Originally Posted by Tremontixriffs) Finally,
Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career as where with kennedy, Alter Bridge will continue to be a great "band" with a seventies/eighties wannabe, not that he is god awlful, I like bridge but creed will be remeber always.

What the hell . . . We dont even know yet if Stapps new single will be successful.

Muad'Dib · 09-13-2005, 06:30 AM

Oh and for AB being a "seventies/eighties wannabe" band, Tremonti has tried to create a different sound then to Creed (although some songs do sound creedish), not just re-using the same formula that made Creed sucessful. Which so far to me is what Stapp is doing. Im sure on the next album AB will develop their own sound a bit more, and show off Myles voice alot more.

uncertaindrumer · 09-13-2005, 09:30 AM

Seventies eighties wannabe band.

First off, all good rock and roll came from the seventies. You can't find good rock any later than that. Sure you can have retardedly generic post grunge alternative, but not rock and roll.

Also, if you can't listen to Myles voice after 20 minutes the problem is with you, not Myles. Someone with real taste in music would never dislike someone just because they are a tenor.

And when you say Stapp is the real deal I laugh. Is this the real deal whose voice was shot throughout his entire last tour? The real deal who got SUED for showing up high at a concert, and was rolling around on the ground?

Stapp has no special lyrical or vocal ability AT ALL. His lyricas are generic lame and boring. His voice is generic lame boring and as of last tour, shot. The reason he had more success is because people can't HANDLE anything that isn't boring. The mainstream does not LIKE talented musicians because it goes over their HEADS. Stapp certainyl goes over NO ONE's head so he was able to get famous on the back of Tremo's ludicrously catchy melodic hooks.

And besides. Stapp is a porky pork. Case closed.

Trimontana · 09-13-2005, 09:50 AM

Quote: (Originally Posted by uncertaindrumer) Seventies eighties wannabe band.
Also, if you can't listen to Myles voice after 20 minutes the problem is with you, not Myles. Someone with real taste in music would never dislike someone just because they are a tenor.

exactly. Myles has an awesome voice. live he even sings better. he can do whatever he wants with his voice.

Quote: And when you say Stapp is the real deal I laugh. Is this the real deal whose voice was shot throughout his entire last tour? The real deal who got SUED for showing up high at a concert, and was rolling around on the ground?

Right as well. Stapp has no special voice whatsoever. He has so many limitations that noone can say hes a real deal.

Quote: Stapp has no special lyrical or vocal ability AT ALL. His lyricas are generic lame and boring. His voice is generic lame boring and as of last tour, shot. The reason he had more success is because people can't HANDLE anything that isn't boring. The mainstream does not LIKE talented musicians because it goes over their HEADS. Stapp certainyl goes over NO ONE's head so he was able to get famous on the back of Tremo's ludicrously catchy melodic hooks.

Of course Stapp voice is boring after a couple of songs.
The difference between Stappy and Tremonti is very easy. Tremonti is not looking for fame and success as a individual. Stapp wants and desires continue be famous, the singer of Creed. Tremonti is having fun and enjoying and showing that doesnt need anyone to compose lurics and music...hes to talented to waist his time next to Stapp.

Quote: And besides. Stapp is a porky pork. Case closed.

Anna1011 · 09-13-2005, 03:55 PM

pft stapps new song is shite sorry if i offend some people on here but its sounds like country music

Trimontana · 09-13-2005, 04:05 PM

Quote: (Originally Posted by Anna1011) pft stapps new song is shite sorry if i offend some people on here but its sounds like country music

i agree with you Anna. I love country music but for someone that still thinks is a rock star sing something like that doesnt suit him at all. the song is aweful, i didnt like it and i suppose that it will have some air time cause sounds very cheese pop country stuff.

Anna1011 · 09-13-2005, 04:07 PM

i was willing to give him a chance but not if his stuffs gonna sound like that. he'll probly do really well with it just cause hes stapp and people already support him but i dont think itll win over many new fans.

Trimontana · 09-13-2005, 04:13 PM

i wanna hear the rst of his stuff but i wont buy it. i wont give to him a cent of my money. anyway i dont think i will like his record but still waiting. about new fans, nope i dont think he will win lot more. cause there are loads of people that still thinks Creed's still together maybe those people will buy his album. lets see tho

Ana4Stapp · 09-13-2005, 05:20 PM

Its A-M-A-Z-I-N-G like some people here love making fun of Stapp all the time but almost die when someone does the same refering to Myles

...

09-12-2005, 05:22 PM	#32
titan9 USER INFO » Status: Bound and Tied Posts: 2,134 Joined: Dec 2004 Currently: Offline	Something tells me if looks were rated 2 and ability 1, that it would be the opposite. Or at least not as lopsided as it is. Or if this were posted at PBF.....nah, bad idea. __________________ Visit the 12 Stones Fan Community, 12stonesfans.com! Check out my friend's Music blog by here!

09-12-2005, 06:26 PM	#33
RMadd USER INFO » Status: Found The Real Posts: 10,546 Joined: Aug 2003 Currently: Offline	stapp's quite the stud, but myles' voice is substantially superior __________________

09-12-2005, 07:54 PM	#34
Tremontixriffs USER INFO » Status: Misconception Posts: 88 Joined: Jul 2005 Currently: Offline	Quote: (Originally Posted by titan9) Something tells me if looks were rated 2 and ability 1, that it would be the opposite. Or at least not as lopsided as it is. Or if this were posted at PBF.....nah, bad idea. Alright people lets be serious looks aside... Myles is a good singer and does have a good range, however his voice leaves alot to be desired...Mainly after about 15- 20 min I cant take listening to him anymore, he almost kills the ears. Maybe some of his songs from Mayfield which were more his style I dont mind. Second Scott stapp is the real deal, He may be arrogant at times or whatever but when it comes down to it he had way more success as a singer and a writer than myles could ever dream. myles may be the better musician and may be a better schooled singer but Stapp didn't need all that to become a great frontman, and when it comes to singing a ballad, kennedy couldn't come close...My ears wanted to blow after listening to in loving memory, it would have sounded so much better had stapp sung it. Finally, Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career as where with kennedy, Alter Bridge will continue to be a great "band" with a seventies/eighties wannabe, not that he is god awlful, I like bridge but creed will be remeber always. __________________ Sometimes it starts with a silent curse Sometimes it doesn't waste time You still think I look upon this with hatred In my mind I won't lie It took some time But I know one thing It took me away from All the things love gave me So I have to let things go... I can go another round Despite you..... I'm still healing... No I'm not real and Yes I'm feeling... This is my fight song Scott Stapp "FIGHT SONG"

09-13-2005, 06:21 AM	#37
Muad'Dib USER INFO » Status: INK'ed Posts: 748 Joined: Jan 2003 Currently: Offline	Quote: (Originally Posted by Tremontixriffs) Finally, Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career as where with kennedy, Alter Bridge will continue to be a great "band" with a seventies/eighties wannabe, not that he is god awlful, I like bridge but creed will be remeber always. What the hell . . . We dont even know yet if Stapps new single will be successful. __________________ I was watching this monkey, this monkey watching me Then I needed a friend, or some company Coz some days I just can’t flick the switch Some days my skin just isn’t so thick

09-13-2005, 06:30 AM	#38
Muad'Dib USER INFO » Status: INK'ed Posts: 748 Joined: Jan 2003 Currently: Offline	Oh and for AB being a "seventies/eighties wannabe" band, Tremonti has tried to create a different sound then to Creed (although some songs do sound creedish), not just re-using the same formula that made Creed sucessful. Which so far to me is what Stapp is doing. Im sure on the next album AB will develop their own sound a bit more, and show off Myles voice alot more. __________________ I was watching this monkey, this monkey watching me Then I needed a friend, or some company Coz some days I just can’t flick the switch Some days my skin just isn’t so thick

09-13-2005, 12:15 AM	#36
ctfan USER INFO » Status: Naked Toddler Posts: 284 Joined: May 2004 Currently: Offline	Stapp gets 3 pts from me. Quote: but when it comes down to it he had way more success as a singer and a writer than myles could ever dream. myles may be the better musician and may be a better schooled singer but Stapp didn't need all that to become a great frontman, and when it comes to singing a ballad, kennedy couldn't come close... Yep. Quote: Myles is a good singer and does have a good range, however his voice leaves alot to be desired...Mainly after about 15- 20 min I cant take listening to him anymore, he almost kills the ears. Yep. Quote: Lets look at it like this, in listening to stapps new single it is ever appearant that he does not need tremonti to have a successful career Yep.

09-13-2005, 09:30 AM	#39
uncertaindrumer USER INFO » Status: Wound Up Posts: 1,255 Joined: Dec 2004 Currently: Offline	Seventies eighties wannabe band. First off, all good rock and roll came from the seventies. You can't find good rock any later than that. Sure you can have retardedly generic post grunge alternative, but not rock and roll. Also, if you can't listen to Myles voice after 20 minutes the problem is with you, not Myles. Someone with real taste in music would never dislike someone just because they are a tenor. And when you say Stapp is the real deal I laugh. Is this the real deal whose voice was shot throughout his entire last tour? The real deal who got SUED for showing up high at a concert, and was rolling around on the ground? Stapp has no special lyrical or vocal ability AT ALL. His lyricas are generic lame and boring. His voice is generic lame boring and as of last tour, shot. The reason he had more success is because people can't HANDLE anything that isn't boring. The mainstream does not LIKE talented musicians because it goes over their HEADS. Stapp certainyl goes over NO ONE's head so he was able to get famous on the back of Tremo's ludicrously catchy melodic hooks. And besides. Stapp is a porky pork. Case closed. __________________ Titans baby, Titans.

09-13-2005, 09:50 AM	#40
Trimontana USER INFO » Status: Bound and Tied Posts: 2,145 Joined: Oct 2004 Currently: Offline	Quote: (Originally Posted by uncertaindrumer) Seventies eighties wannabe band. Also, if you can't listen to Myles voice after 20 minutes the problem is with you, not Myles. Someone with real taste in music would never dislike someone just because they are a tenor. exactly. Myles has an awesome voice. live he even sings better. he can do whatever he wants with his voice. Quote: And when you say Stapp is the real deal I laugh. Is this the real deal whose voice was shot throughout his entire last tour? The real deal who got SUED for showing up high at a concert, and was rolling around on the ground? Right as well. Stapp has no special voice whatsoever. He has so many limitations that noone can say hes a real deal. Quote: Stapp has no special lyrical or vocal ability AT ALL. His lyricas are generic lame and boring. His voice is generic lame boring and as of last tour, shot. The reason he had more success is because people can't HANDLE anything that isn't boring. The mainstream does not LIKE talented musicians because it goes over their HEADS. Stapp certainyl goes over NO ONE's head so he was able to get famous on the back of Tremo's ludicrously catchy melodic hooks. Of course Stapp voice is boring after a couple of songs. The difference between Stappy and Tremonti is very easy. Tremonti is not looking for fame and success as a individual. Stapp wants and desires continue be famous, the singer of Creed. Tremonti is having fun and enjoying and showing that doesnt need anyone to compose lurics and music...hes to talented to waist his time next to Stapp. Quote: And besides. Stapp is a porky pork. Case closed. __________________ Papa Roach's Tobin Esperance: "If you're gonna wear makeup, it's not about looking pretty. It's gotta look like you've been up all night doing drugs." Last edited by Trimontana : 09-13-2005 at 03:13 PM.

09-13-2005, 04:05 PM	#42
Trimontana USER INFO » Status: Bound and Tied Posts: 2,145 Joined: Oct 2004 Currently: Offline	Quote: (Originally Posted by Anna1011) pft stapps new song is shite sorry if i offend some people on here but its sounds like country music i agree with you Anna. I love country music but for someone that still thinks is a rock star sing something like that doesnt suit him at all. the song is aweful, i didnt like it and i suppose that it will have some air time cause sounds very cheese pop country stuff. __________________ Papa Roach's Tobin Esperance: "If you're gonna wear makeup, it's not about looking pretty. It's gotta look like you've been up all night doing drugs."

09-13-2005, 04:13 PM	#44
Trimontana USER INFO » Status: Bound and Tied Posts: 2,145 Joined: Oct 2004 Currently: Offline	i wanna hear the rst of his stuff but i wont buy it. i wont give to him a cent of my money. anyway i dont think i will like his record but still waiting. about new fans, nope i dont think he will win lot more. cause there are loads of people that still thinks Creed's still together maybe those people will buy his album. lets see tho __________________ Papa Roach's Tobin Esperance: "If you're gonna wear makeup, it's not about looking pretty. It's gotta look like you've been up all night doing drugs."

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

User Name		Remember Me?
Password