|
"I love both Soundgarden and Pearl Jam, but Eddie Vedder can write circles around Chris Cornell lyrically. Vedder is one of the most amazing storytellers EVER. When I listen to PJ, I get pictures in my mind of the people in his stories, his songs. And the stories make you feel. Not that Cornell can't write, because I love Soundgarden a ton, but Vedder is just an awesome writer.
And McCready is the shit. Again, this is a player who plays with feel along with skill. What about Black? That guitar almost speaks to you in that song, and that's just one example. Also, for chops, check out November Hotel on the Mad Season CD and tell me he isn't kick-ass.
And right on, hide, about PJ evolving and changing and not giving in to the formulaic crap that pervades radio. What they put out is a gazillion times deeper, cerebral and entertaining than crap like the pseudo-punk pop bands all over the charts. I like music that takes me on a trip, that makes me think, that makes me feel. Both Soundgarden and Pearl Jam do that for me."
OK good a decent point, i will contend that Vedder is a very good writer. But remember that Cornell sings, plays guitar and writes lyrics. So i am guessing Cornell has a lot of influence in the instumental portion of the music. SG seems like a more music orientated band. In fact i love how the instrumentals sends my imagination into overdrive. It puts me into a place no words can describe. (Some songs that make me thinks this is Black hole sun, Overfloater, Zero Chance, and Blow up the outside world). Pearl Jam just doesn't do it for me. But i guess it just depends on what you are into.
Again, we are comparing PJ to SG, if McCready can out play Thayil it isn't apparent in PJ's music.
See my reponse to Aussiecreeder.
|