CreedFeed Community - View Single Post

BSC · 11-06-2009, 04:42 AM

Quote: (Originally Posted by Futanical) To some of the people questioning why he is so great on record and not live, news flash .. it's called The Studio and they can make ANYONE on planet earth sound like they have a voice and can pull off insane notes they wouldn't be able to otherwise without the technology in the studio.

Now, I am a recording arts major - One thing a vocalist should never ever ever do is write a melody they can't pull off live. There is NO WAY he pulled those songs off in the studio without some MAJOR vocal enhancement and pitch correction. You're not going to convince me he did, either. Therefore, he wrote melodies and pitches he couldn't pull off live which his own damn fault. He is baratone and screaming high notes makes him look desperate.

With respect, do you know what you are talking about?

Why do we all act like we know everything about Stapp...?

For all we know he could have blown his voice in the studio, but nothing is ever that simple on these forums are they?

Yeah his voice has probably been auto-tuned, and so has Mark's, and every other singer's voice on records, but we act like we know every little detail.

It's ridiculous.

When Scott tells us why he can't sing very well live at the moment, in detail. I'll believe you.

11-06-2009, 04:42 AM	#47
BSC USER INFO » Status: A Melody Posts: 348 Joined: Jun 2009 Currently: Offline	Re: Tonight Show Quote: (Originally Posted by Futanical) To some of the people questioning why he is so great on record and not live, news flash .. it's called The Studio and they can make ANYONE on planet earth sound like they have a voice and can pull off insane notes they wouldn't be able to otherwise without the technology in the studio. Now, I am a recording arts major - One thing a vocalist should never ever ever do is write a melody they can't pull off live. There is NO WAY he pulled those songs off in the studio without some MAJOR vocal enhancement and pitch correction. You're not going to convince me he did, either. Therefore, he wrote melodies and pitches he couldn't pull off live which his own damn fault. He is baratone and screaming high notes makes him look desperate. With respect, do you know what you are talking about? Why do we all act like we know everything about Stapp...? For all we know he could have blown his voice in the studio, but nothing is ever that simple on these forums are they? Yeah his voice has probably been auto-tuned, and so has Mark's, and every other singer's voice on records, but we act like we know every little detail. It's ridiculous. When Scott tells us why he can't sing very well live at the moment, in detail. I'll believe you.