Well I certainly didn't attend the last 95% of the Weathered tour, but I know people who did attend various shows. I'd even venture to say that every single show was reported on at the message boards and setlists were posted. Not to mention that bootlegs have surfaced for many of said shows. So it's not very far fetched for someone who's been around the fansites for a while to make a statement like that.
And as for the question.... I was told that Signs, in particular, did not 'go over' very well, as far as crowd response. I can completely see that, too. I just couldn't get into that one song very well.