[uncertaindrumer]

Quote: (Originally Posted by PrtytilImPurple)

Well if the guy's voice grates on your last nerve you could say he sucks. Go to places like Amazon.com. Look up One Day Remains and read the reviews that the people who bought the album posted. For every two that love the stuff, their is another person who doesn't like it. Either because they think lyrically it isn't that good or that they don't like the singer's voice. I'm not making it up. Go look for yourself.

Just because the guy is technically proficient doesn't mean he's a master. If the voice don't carry any emotion behind it then to some people its just noise. Hittin all the right notes is only part of the artistry. I know people who couldn't stand Guns n Roses because of Axl's voice. Thats the problem with being a tenor. Some you like and some you don't.

There is a huge difference between something not carrying emotion and something be BAD. First, you are correct, whether or not you feel emotional (or you feel HE is carrying emotion) is completely subjective.

But then again, I don't think ANY prog rock carries ANY emtoion but I am not so bull-headed as to say they SUCK.

Also, I find it funny how half of the people who hate AB hate hem because "they sound jsut like Creed and Myles sounds just like Stapp" and the other half hate them because "they sound nothing like Creed and Myles sounds nothing like Stapp".

Kinda ironic.

Anyway, on topic, the letter still looks fake to me. It just doesn't FEEL like something that guy would write... Plus, like someone said: he would not sign Creed in his name. He is not THAT stupid.