So, besides the new singer for the project, Is brian Going to be in this band? I hope so. Perhaps this could be a new begining for creed and turn into a permanent deal. Kinda like an audioslave deal.

so youre saying they just get a new singer and become bigger than the original band? its goin to be hard to be bigger than Creed

I don't think they will be half as big as Creed but as long as great music is put out. I hear these Marshall rumours and it would be good if they can all patch up their differences.

i think they could be at least Socialburn famous

<!--QuoteBegin-CollectiveSoul+12-05-2003 07:15 AM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (CollectiveSoul @ 12-05-2003 07:15 AM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin--> i think they could be at least Socialburn famous [/b][/quote]
heh - seeing the new "Creed" band at The Rave for $15... that would be awsome!! Beats going to Alpine Valley Ampitheater and paying over $50!

sounds good to me :banana:

He's in. I mean, Brian is practing with Mark and Flip, but he didn't sign a contract yet.

I'm thinking maybe Stapp could record it and they can get another singer for touring. Do you think that could be possible? It would be cool and good for everybody. ehh... not that good

<!--QuoteBegin-musicmind226+12-05-2003 03:24 AM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (musicmind226 @ 12-05-2003 03:24 AM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin-->So, besides the new singer for the project, Is brian Going to be in this band? I hope so. Perhaps this could be a new begining for creed and turn into a permanent deal. Kinda like an audioslave deal.[/b][/quote]
Creed isn't Creed without Stapp. If they wanna do their own music, fine and good...but if they think they can recreate Creed with a different singer...its simply four guys trying to be the same band they came from. Audioslave doesn't sound like the two bands that make them up. I don't wanna hear some re-hashed Creed sound-alike...I prefer the real thing. If they wanna do their own thing, then do something different, and don't try to cash in on Creed's success by imitating it.

<!--QuoteBegin-Jooji_2+12-05-2003 03:46 PM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (Jooji_2 @ 12-05-2003 03:46 PM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin--> Creed isn't Creed without Stapp. If they wanna do their own music, fine and good...but if they think they can recreate Creed with a different singer...its simply four guys trying to be the same band they came from. Audioslave doesn't sound like the two bands that make them up. I don't wanna hear some re-hashed Creed sound-alike...I prefer the real thing. If they wanna do their own thing, then do something different, and don't try to cash in on Creed's success by imitating it. [/b][/quote]
blah blah blah blah

Dear Stapp lil widow,

Audioslave has a completely different concept from RATM. They didn't want the same kind of music.

The new band is gonna rock, with or without Stapp, just face it: Creed wasn't a band of one man, it was a gathering of talented musicians. 3 of them are still the same. Creed's sucess was only due Stapp's voice and lyrics (50% percent of them written by Mark as well). Look at the number of Tremonti wanna bes on Creed boards... look how many bassists still admire Brian. Flip has his own fan site.

Welcome to the real world!

I do believe she was agreeing with musicmind in her post ;)

<!--QuoteBegin-facelessman+12-04-2003 10:42 PM--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (facelessman @ 12-04-2003 10:42 PM)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'><!--QuoteEBegin--> so youre saying they just get a new singer and become bigger than the original band? its goin to be hard to be bigger than Creed [/b][/quote]
Hell yeah it's going to be hard to beat out anything Creed did. I'm sorry Mark but if you're going to do this new band and don't find a good lead singer then it's not going to sell. So much of the media attention and radio play is based on a band's lead singer these days. I think Scott would do fine on a solo project, but Mark would have to find a singer.

I would guess they'll change if Tremo has anything to do w/ it (which he will)... after all, he's more into the metal stuff, so....

theyll be fine

Seriously, am I the only person who seems optomistic about this side project? Personally I think it will kick ass. Also, there are to many stapp fanatics, if you think scott stapp is god, fine, but he's not. And obviously, he wanted to do something of his own for awhile. Bands do change, and logically I think it won't e quite as big as creed because there no stapp, and so many people viewd creed like stapp was he only member. Remeber there were two other members, three if you counted brett.

Hell, this has not even become a total reality, meaning this band has not toally formed, so why bash it? Or talk like nothing good at ALL can come from this. If flip, brian, and tremo wanted to cash in on creeds success, then would it not be just as easy to get a singer that sounds just like stapp? I mean, the fact that there holding audiontions indicates other wise. This project will be whats it's going to be, like it or lump it. And I'm sure as hell am not going to be so ignorant as to jump to conclusions when it's not happend yet.

i think Tremonti and flip will rock like none other

musicmind don't get me wrong I am looking foreward this project but hopefully they go down a different route and it doesn't sound like Creed with a new singer. I would also like to see a singer more like Cornell not somoene who sounds like Stapp.

i dont care who they get, as long as they can rock

I can't wait to hear Mark go fully sick and have a solo that will be remembered such as the gunners Sweet O' Child of Mine.

I think the creed is not creed without the members, be who goes that skirt will leave a terrible emptiness in the band. Mark gets to reconcile the guitar with the letter and it passes emotion through the music besides contributing with the letter, Stapp with your vocal excellent and your letters and Flip with your energy in the drums. If some leaves Creed it loses your essence. None of them is more important than the other, a band is a band and not only a person. That is my opinion.

yeah

All I can say is that I hope both "factions" are able to gain valuable experience apart from each other, and then fuse back together. Creed would then have a really interesting new sound... a mix between G n' R and Audioslave would be sweet. I've always thought of Creed as band that combined all the sounds of the 90s and 80s (and 70s) together.

yeah!

blah blah blah blah

Dear Stapp lil widow,

Audioslave has a completely different concept from RATM. They didn't want the same kind of music.

The new band is gonna rock, with or without Stapp, just face it: Creed wasn't a band of one man, it was a gathering of talented musicians. 3 of them are still the same. Creed's sucess was only due Stapp's voice and lyrics (50% percent of them written by Mark as well). Look at the number of Tremonti wanna bes on Creed boards... look how many bassists still admire Brian. Flip has his own fan site.

Welcome to the real world![/quote]

Why is it that people who want to give EVERY member of the group credit for the success are called Stapp Nuts or Lil Stapp Widows, or Stapp Fanatics or Stapp Stalkers? Hey....I'm not the one with a band members name in my username. You think they sold over 20 million albums on the merits of their drummer, bassist and guitar player? Actually it was a gathering of 4 talented musicians. At least you got the point I was trying to make about Audioslave....they didn't copy their respective previous bands. That was the point I was making about this all consuming "new band" idea....hey make all the rocking music you want....all this talk about how Tremonti was being held back....if that's so...then lets see what the dude can do. But if all he does is recreate Creed...what was it that was holding him back?

How about telling me which songs are Tremonti's.....I'm betting you know every one of them. And I'm guessing you are one of those Tremonti wannabes?

Joomanji,

You're so, but so far from my point and from what I said.

My post was adressed to the member who was bashing Mark, as if it was his fault. Translating: it wasn't addresed to you.

Every Stapp mamma is assuming it's Mark's fault, just because he's the one who slipped it off. IMHO, it's unfair, since people are judging but aren't based on FACTS.

That's it. So long, read with more attention next time.... :)

I am really surprised by the number of people who are all excited about the members of Creed splitting up and doing their own thing. I'm sure that each of them will remain successful, because they are all talented individuals, but I don't think they will come close to matching what they would have if they were to remain together. Their stage presence was amazing, and it wouldn't have been that way if it were not for the chemistry that they had together.
I know that they are only a band, and none of us can control what they choose to do, but I want Creed :(

Hey Mr. Tremonti Dude......you quoted MY post...so wasn't it safe to say you were addressing me???? Nothing wrong with my reading comprehension. Don't believe I was assigning any blame to anyone...IMHO I just stated I didn't want to hear Tremonti trying to recreate Creed. If he wants to be free to be himself...then be it. You don't ever believe crap that isn't based on fact do you???? What....I've seen some posts here where you did just that!!!!! The band members are the only people who know why anything happened....unless you have some clairvoyant connection to one of them and your information is fact, you know no more than I do. You still didn't answer my question......I'm interested in knowing which songs were written by Tremonti....I have no idea which ones are his....I'd be interested in finding out. Come on.....fill me in.

Tremonti wrote 50% of the lyrics wo nelly your making me laugh too hard! LOL

Tremonti wrote Torn and I believe the choruses to My Sacrifice and My Own Prison but I would be surprised if he wrote anymore then this apart from his spoken parts.

musicmind...are you rocker

I have thought of you since this all happened and wondered what you though particularly about Brett apparently not being included and Brian taking his place?

Excuse me mamm but Brett took Brian's place not the other way around, so I am not sure why you would think he would be included? Brett was also a stand in never meant to be a part of Creed. Brett has always been a man of his own with his own band and his own style, he just was helping the band out when he stepped in. Brian was an orginal member of Creed.

I quoted your post coz of the Audioslave remark... never intended to quote YOU...

anyway, get to know me, newbie, before you judge me, coz you seem to miss when I'm being sarcastic and when I'm not.

they never explicited the songs Mark wrote: we know he did Torn, most of Hide... collaboration, you know.

Too much drama and bickering here. Starting to feel like the Pit.

Got that right! Why does everyone need the sarcasm (sp.?) We all used to get along just fine here at the Feed......what happened people? :(

nothing happened. we all love each other

I think I get your sarcasm just fine. And the name is Jooji......not lil Stapp widow, stapp mamma or Joomanji. Okay...thanks for filling me in.....Torn, Hide....some of My Sacrifice and some of MOP.

We still get along, but it's just all of the crap that's going on with the band at the moment, it's pretty intense. (As if you haven't noticed). It's alot to handle. I have tried to steer clear of the posts on The Band, because it get's too heated up for me.

Creed Feed and the people haven't changed.

I get along fine with people who respect that I have an opinion, even if they don't agree with it......and people who don't talk down to me. That's my problem with this dude.

meh

Teri.
You took the words out of my mouth. As I was reading (and being reprimanded by someone from the pit) I thought OMG, not here too.

Sistah Sami...I know EXACTLY who Brian and Brett are.

You may not have noticed that my post was directed at a specific person who I happen to know from another board. He and I have been involved in a number of threads about the subject of Brett way before this happened...months ago in fact.

Musicmind has a terrific knowledge of music and musicians and I respect his opinion. When I saw him here I was honestly asking for his thoughts. We have exchanged thoughts on various issues.

Of course. everyone can respond, this is a public board, but I didn't expect to be treated like an idiot at CREEDFEED.

BTW, didn't I see a number of threads on the Pit over the months about Brett and ppl hoping he would be part of the band and wondering what role he would play in Creed's future. I'm sure you set them straight too.

I agree Teri, we don't need this stuff here for crying out loud. This is a peaceful board.

Dear human being!!!!!!! How long will it take until you reckon I wasn't talking to you????????????????????

ahhhhhhh... you keep seeking for a "polite" reply of me... talk to my hand.

Brian Marshall
 

Why yes I am, great to be here I tell you. However, ....hmmm.....well.....I actully viewd brett as some what of a member of creed.