No, wasn't saying that.

I would like to give an example here Stevie Nicks was in fleetwood mac when she wrote landslide and I saw her do this at ceasars palace in las vegas 4 times this summer, and it was amazing the crowd went nuts! and it was incredible! so if Stapp does something like What If at his shows :smokin: :smokin: I can't wait! and for those who don't care to here him do old creed songs well then don't pay to go to his shows? thats pretty much your choice?

i don't mind him doing the songs, i just think on this radio promo for his new album he should stick to new songs...maybe that's cause we haven't heard any of his new stuff, other than TGD, and i want to hear more...but even if not that, it just seems weird for him to do creed to promote solo stapp.

Then you were saying....?

Exactly, Chris Cornell has done both Soundgarden AND Rage Against the Machine Songs at Audioslave concerts. The same goes for Scott Weiland in Velvet Revolver... he's done Stone Temple Pilot songs.

Ive made this statement many times, and i will make it one more time. I think that stapp shouldnt do any creed songs. Basically because that is utter disrespect to Alter Bridge and Creed fans. Think about it. If you were in a highly sucessful band, sold millions of albums, made millions of dollars, then split up, would you want one of the other members of the band capitalizing off of your blood, sweat, and tears. Last i checked, Scott stapp doesnt play guitar (very well) drums, or bass....So what gives Goneblind the right to play the backing instruments to the songs that Tremonti, Flip, and Marshall made. Its absurd to think that stapp would do that. Before you think that what im saying is "one sided" think about what you would do if you and one of your friends wrote an awesome story for literature class, and then the next day your friend walked into the classroom, handed in the entire story, and got credit for something that you worked on as well.

why should he care about alter bridge fans?
If creed fans pay to hear his concert knowing that he will play a couple creed songs, they probably don't mind.
how would he be capitalizing off it? I doubt he will sell many tickets to people who want to sit through the majority of a concert just to hear 1 or 2 songs at the end. They will most likely be paying to hear his new stuff. A couple of covers will just be a bonus.
How would credit be taken away from the other guys? Nobody can replace them. Plus from another thread, I think it is the consensus that gone blind sucked playing Higher for the nascar awards (I thought they did too). Unless they just didn't have time to practice it enough, I don't think many people will want to hear Creed songs with that setup. I don't think it is absurd that the former lead singer covers a few songs for the fans if it doesn't suck like previously mentioned. Probably won't ever be the same or as good, but it might be cool with a decent band behind him.

Well, apparently someone wouldnt mind if their friend stole their homework assignment. Believe me, i kinda like stapp, dont really dig his new song that much, but its ok. He was a part of a band that i loved for years, and to be quite honest with you, if i do get tickets to a show of his, and he does play a creed song, i will be the first to boo his ass off the stage. Its a musician thing, you have to be a musician in order to respect another musicians point of view on this kind of matter. I dont respect scott stapp for deciding to play creed songs on tour, and i think that overall, he will recieve a lot of bad feedback for it. Would you still respect him if he put a creed song on his new album. Believe me, if Alter bridge played creed songs on tour, i would lose quite a bit of respect for them, and mark tremonti is the reason i play guitar today. Scott stapp is my vocal influence, it takes a lot for a musician to lose respect for an influence, but stapp crossed a very bad line with me when he did Higher with Gonedeaf, i mean blind, at that Nascar award show.

I think you are just a wannabee! and I cant wait to hear the creed songs he wrote and is planning on performing! we want creed songs! you are in the minority here. and if you know he's doing creed songs and dont want to hear them then don't go! you aren't welcome trust me! and alter bridge live well I saw them and they were lousy no magic here...

A wannabe what? Your intelligent comments are underwhelming in quantity.


Good for you.


No, YOU want Creed songs.



Don't let the fact that you are on a SCOTT STAPP board fool you. No Stapp fan will EVER be in the majority on ANYTHING related to him. The majority either hates his guts, is sick of him, or doesn't even remember him. And for the sake of argument let's say you were in the majority. Would that change anything? Uh... NO. The majority means that more people agree with you then disagree. It doesn't make it right or wrong.


Good advice, that. But it is not the point. The point is that he is mooching off of other's success. I could not really care about Creed songs in the first place since I think 3/4 of them suck. But if I was in a band, wrote ALL of the music to EVERY song, then split up, made my own band and let the old band R.I.P., I would be rather ticked off if someone else went around living off of my hits. So would you. You just let your personal bias stand in the way of your judgement.



Like you have any business saying anything like that. Your arrogance and lack of civility are OVERwhelming.


What is it with Stapp fans and cheap shots? This has nothing to do with Alter Bridge's live show. Who gives a crap about AB's live show? First off, they do put on a heck of a show, but second, why on Earth would you bring that up? The only possible reason would be to piss people off, and in that you succeeded. You pissed me off. And you can ask Ana4Stapp what happens to people who piss me off :cool:

:(

LOL Uncertain!!! You want me to say that all of them were ...BANNED??? :rolleyes:

So you are going to ban people for their opinions because they aren't the same as yours?

YOU want Creed songs. Creed is over, Creed were 4 people and NOT just an individual. If Stapp would love Creed that much he would respect the fact that Creed wasnt just himself but obviously hes just a selfish person. Thats why i couldnt never go to one of his gig cause i dont respect him even like a musician. Even like musician his only sell himself as that he was and not cause his new material. If thats the way is gonna be, he cant count that i will be buying his cd.

I don't ban anybody. I am not a moderator or anything close. There is just this weird problem of everyone who ever gets into a big argument with me getting banned... seriously, it is like an epidemic.